Division Series preview: White Sox-Guardians

Fri, Oct. 9 · 7 finals around the world · 4 roster moves · Stat Lab #16: WAR, built from its components · 5-min read

Press time 12:00 CEST

Tonight (CEST)

Sat, Oct. 10 · 1 game · none before 23:00 CEST · starters as of 12:00 CEST

MatchupStart CEST (ET)SeriesAway SPHome SPStakes
CWS 84-78
@ CLE 85-77
Sun 02:00
(8:00 p.m.)
ALDS G5 of 5
tied 2-2
Sean Burke
3.34 · 3.62 · 17.2% · 172.1
Gavin Williams
3.76 · 3.47 · 25.1% · 184.1
winner-take-all
Prague time (CEST), US Eastern in brackets; final regular-season W-L. SP: announced probable starter (TBD = not yet), season ERA · FIP · K-BB% · IP; a/b GS = starts/games for a pitcher who mostly relieves. Stakes: series score as of this morning. ● = starts before 23:00 CEST.

Postseason Preview

Division Series (best of five) · first pitch Sun, Oct. 11, 02:00 CEST (8:00 p.m. ET).

White Sox at Guardians

TeamW-LRun diffPythag W-LLast 10Streak
Guardians85-77+1182-808-2L1
White Sox84-78+5687-757-3W1

Game 5: Sun, Oct. 11, 02:00 CEST (8:00 p.m. ET) · run-differential edge: White Sox by 45.

Dodgers at Brewers

TeamW-LRun diffPythag W-LLast 10Streak
Brewers103-59+214103-598-2W5
Dodgers100-62+201102-608-2W3

Game 1: Mon, Oct. 12, 02:00 CEST (8:00 p.m. ET) · run-differential edge: Brewers by 13.

The Bracket

Wild Card Series (best of three, every game at the higher seed)

  • AL: White Sox at Astros: White Sox win 2-0.
  • AL: Red Sox at Yankees: Yankees win 2-0.
  • NL: Phillies at Braves: Braves win 2-1.
  • NL: Cubs at Padres: Padres win 2-0.

Division Series (best of five)

  • AL: Yankees at Rays: Rays win 3-0.
  • AL: White Sox at Guardians: Tied 2-2 · Game 5: Sun, Oct. 11, 02:00 CEST (8:00 p.m. ET) · history: tied 2-2, the team at home in Game 5 (Guardians) won 26 of 52.
  • NL: Padres at Brewers: Brewers win 3-1.
  • NL: Braves at Dodgers: Dodgers win 3-1.

Championship Series (best of seven)

  • AL: Tampa Bay Rays hosts CLE/CWS (slots still open).
  • NL: Dodgers at Brewers: Not started · Game 1: Mon, Oct. 12, 02:00 CEST (8:00 p.m. ET).

Stat Lab · Lesson 16: WAR, built from its components

Pete Crow-Armstrong of the Cubs owns a season worth 10.6 WAR, the most of any hitter in baseball. Everyone quotes that number. Few can say what is inside it, so let’s open it up.

The idea. WAR asks one question: how many more wins did this player add than a replacement-level player, the kind of fringe big leaguer a club can find for the minimum salary? It is built in runs. Batting (from wRAA, adjusted for the ballpark), baserunning and fielding measure him against an average player. The positional adjustment credits hard positions like catcher, shortstop and center field and charges easy ones like first base and designated hitter. A small league adjustment levels the AL and NL. Then comes the replacement credit: what an average player is worth over a replacement player in the same playing time.

The math. In runs: batting +49.4, baserunning +8.2, fielding +21.1, positional +1.9, league +1.5, replacement +22.1, for a total of 104.2 runs above replacement. This season one win costs 9.82 runs, the same figure for every player, so 104.2 ÷ 9.82 = 10.6 WAR. His batting runs (+49.4) and his wRAA (+48.8) differ by 0.6: that is the adjustment for his ballpark and league.

ComponentRunsRunning total
Batting+49.4+49.4
Baserunning+8.2+57.6
Fielding+21.1+78.7
Positional adjustment+1.9+80.6
League adjustment+1.5+82.1
Replacement level+22.1+104.2
÷ runs per win9.8210.6 WAR
Pete Crow-Armstrong’s 10.6 WAR, built from runs

The scale. A rough WAR scale for a full season: under 1 is a bench player, about 2 a solid regular, 3 to 4 a good one, 5 an All-Star and 6-plus MVP territory. Among the 156 hitters with 450-plus plate appearances, Pete Crow-Armstrong’s 10.6 ranks first. Take away the replacement credit and he is still 82.1 runs, or 8.4 wins, better than an average player. WAR’s zero is replacement, not average, which is why an everyday average player earns about 1.9 wins per 600 plate appearances just by holding the job.

What it doesn’t tell you:

  • Fielding runs are the shakiest part: defensive metrics disagree with each other and need several seasons to settle, so his +21.1 carries a wide error bar.
  • Treat WAR as a range, not a ranking. Two players half a win apart are, for practical purposes, even.
  • There is more than one WAR. FanGraphs and Baseball-Reference build theirs with different fielding models and baselines, and the same season can differ by a win or more between them.

Try it. Take a player from last night’s box scores, find his WAR components, and rebuild the total yourself: add the six run values and divide by 9.82. Which piece carries him?

Go deeper: MLB Glossary: WAR · FanGraphs Library: WAR for position players · FanGraphs Library: replacement level · FanGraphs Library: WAR’s limitations

Check yourself

  • Q1. If Pete Crow-Armstrong had been an exactly average fielder, how much WAR would he lose?
  • Q2. Why does an average everyday player have a positive WAR?
  • Q3. Why does a shortstop get a positional bonus and a first baseman a penalty?
Show answers
  • A1. 2.1 wins: his +21.1 fielding runs ÷ 9.82.
  • A2. Because WAR’s zero is replacement level, not average. An average regular earns about 1.9 wins per 600 plate appearances just by being better than the fringe players who would replace him.
  • A3. Shortstop is much harder to play, so an average hitter who can play it is scarcer and more valuable. The adjustment lets players at different positions be compared on one scale.

Transaction Wire

  • Braves: designated SS Luke Williams for assignment · MLB Trade Rumors
  • Braves: selected LHP Danny Young from Gwinnett Stripers · MLB Trade Rumors
  • White Sox: status change for RHP Luis Castillo
  • Dodgers: status change for RHP Blake Treinen

Around the World

  • KBO (Korea): Twins 1, Giants 9 · Tigers 7, Dinos 2 · Lions 1, Landers 3
  • CPBL (Taiwan): Lions 1, Brothers 4 (Challenge Series Game 1)
  • Arizona Fall League: Javelinas 10, Saguaros 4 · Solar Sox 10, Scorpions 11 (walk-off) · Desert Dogs 9, Rafters 13

Around the Web

News

Transactions & Rumors

Analysis · Listen (7)

Analysis

Listen


Sources & Notes

Built automatically from MLB Stats API, MyKBO Stats and CPBL Stats data; numbers through Oct. 9, 2026, with FIP, xFIP, WAR and wRC+ up to a day behind. The information used here was obtained free of charge from and is copyrighted by Retrosheet. Interested parties may contact Retrosheet at “www.retrosheet.org”. How this site works